Khan al Ahmar
The West Bank Palestinian village of Khan al Ahmar is at imminent risk of demolition. The village is located near Jerusalem, between the Israeli settlement of Ma’ale Adumim and one of its elite suburbs, Kfar Adumim. It is one of several Palestinian communities facing forced relocation because it falls within the “E1” plan that would link the Israeli settlements with West Jerusalem (cutting East Jerusalem off from the rest of the West Bank). All the homes and structures in Khan al Ahmar were issued demolition orders on March 5th, 2017, requiring them to demolish their own homes, school, mosque, clinic, and barns within seven days. Of grave concern is that when Adv. Shlomo Lecker, the attorney for Khan Al Ahmar, filed a petition to appeal, the judge on duty failed to issue an informal preliminary injunction against demolition until March 13th. Under the preliminary injunction, Khan al Ahmar was protected until March 30th at which point the State of Israel was supposed to announce its official position on the village.
Khan al Ahmar is home to 32 families (about 173 people, including 92 minors). On September 24th, 2017, the government of Israel submitted its position to the High Court, asking that plans be approved to demolish the entire village by mid-2018 and forcibly relocate its residents to the town of Abu Dis. On Monday, September 25th, the High Court announced a postponement for a decision to be made on this case until April 2018. The Court is considering two petitions: one from a settler group demanding that the village be evacuated, and one from Khan al Ahmar residents, pleading for their village to remain standing. Human rights groups have stated that the execution of these plans would legally be tantamount to a war crime.
The lawyer representing Khan al Ahmar, at the time of this writing, had been given 25 to re-submit the petition to the High Court.
Legal details of the Khan al Ahmar case
Each and every structure in the village of Khan al Ahmar was placed under demolition orders on March 5th, 2017. 44 separate orders were issued to the village’s 160 structures — including their school, clinic, mosque, and all the homes — escalating the stop-work orders issued a week prior.
The entire village had been placed under demolition orders previously, but had been granted an injunction against demolition by the Israeli High Court pending a plan by the State of Israel as to where these villagers would be moved. The new demolition orders issued on March 5th are an attempt to circumvent the injunction.
The village was given seven days to demolish their own community, brick-by-brick, including their homes, school, mosque, and medical clinic.
On March 2nd, Adv. Shlomo Lecker, the Israeli lawyer representing Khan Al Ahmar, filed an emergency petition requesting an injunction against demolition from the High Court of Israel.
In a breach of procedure, Justice Noam Sohlberg (who is himself an Israeli settler, and ought to recuse himself for conflict of interest), the judge on duty at Israel’s High Court, did not reply for almost two weeks. As a result of Justice Sohlberg’s failure to issue the requested injunction in a timely manner, Khan al Ahmar was at risk of demolition before their appeal is heard by Israel’s High Court.
On March 13th, a preliminary injunction against demolition was issued to Khan al Ahmar. This informal order protects the village at least until March 30th, when the State was expected to give its official position on the village.
The Israeli government proposed moving the residents of Khan al Ahmar to Nuwei’ma, near Jericho. They rejected this plan, which would place them in close proximity with an Israeli settlement, as well as an IDF camp, and provide no land for their sheep and goats. Then, the Israeli government proposed forcibly transferring the residents to a town called Abu Dis.
The reason demolition orders are issued to Khan al Ahmar is that they do not have ICA-issued building permits for their structures. When they applied for building permits they were told that permits cannot be issued because the village does not have a master zoning plan. When they filed a professionally-developed master plan in 2014, it was rejected due to questions about land ownership. About a month later, the village submitted five alternative master plans. These have not yet been reviewed.
The community’s existence poses an obstacle to the expansion and annexation of the Israeli settlement of Ma’ale Adumim and its suburbs, which is the underlying reason its master plan was not approved.
In a letter addressed to Prime Minister Netanyahu and Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman, among others, B’Tselem Executive Director Hagai El-Ad warns that forcible transfer of a civilian population in an occupied territory is a war crime.
As of October 23rd, 2017, the village is again at imminent risk of demolition. The Israeli High Court had postponed its decision on this case until April 2018, but now it appears they will make the decision within the next month, at which point the village could be demolished. The Court is considering two petitions: one from settlers, and one from Khan al Ahmar residents.
About Khan al Ahmar
· Khan al Ahmar is a Palestinian Bedouin village, inhabited by the Jahalin tribe, located in Area C of the West Bank, between the Israeli settlement of Ma’ale Adumim and one of its elite suburbs, Kfar Adumim. This places it within the E1 plan that would cut off Palestinian access to Jerusalem.
· The residents of Khan al Ahmar were forcibly relocated from the village of Tel Arad in Israel’s Negev Desert in 1951. They leased the land that they now live on from a private Palestinian landowner in Anata until it was expropriated and declared State land in 1975, zoned for the establishment of an industrial zone and later for the settlement of Ma’ale Adumim.
· There are approximately 32 families (173 individuals; 92 of them minors) that call Khan al Ahmar home.
· The village’s extraordinary elementary school was built in 2009 by an Italian organization, Venti di Terra. It was constructed using tires and mud. It currently serves 174 students from Khan al Ahmar and the neighboring area. Construction of the local school made education accessible for many children, especially girls, as parents previously had felt it too dangerous to allow their children to cross the highway on foot to reach distant schools.
About Area C and the Master Planning Process
· The Olso Accords split the West Bank into Areas A, B, and C. Area C is temporarily administered by the Israeli Civil Administration (the bureaucratic arm of Israeli Army) but, per the Oslo Accords, the administration of land was to have transferred back to Palestinian control within 18 months after the formation of the Palestinian Legislative Council.
· Most of Area C is zoned for Israeli use, and over 400,000 Israelis live in about 130 separate settlements, although this is against international laws of military occupation.
· Palestinian communities’ master plans must be approved by the Israeli Civil Administration, or they are at risk of demolition. 108 technically-sound plans have been professionally developed and submitted to the ICA since 2011, but only three have been approved.
· Plans are rejected for spurious reasons, like the assertion that infrastructure will be impossible to implement. This is baseless, as Israeli settlements enjoy well-developed modern infrastructure.
Serious Escalation in the Demolition of Palestinian Homes
· Israel has aggressively escalated the demolition of Palestinian homes, barns, and wells. According to the U.N. Office of Coordination for Humanitarian Affairs, there has been over a 50% increase in the rate of demolitions in January 2017 (140 structures demolished) compared with January 2016 (91 structures). There were more demolitions in 2016 than any year since 1967.
· There is a 12 Km. swath of land between the settlement of Ma’ale Adumim and Jerusalem deemed East 1, or E1, by the Israeli government. The slated annexation of E1 makes the two-state solution next to impossible as its annexation would cut East Jerusalem off from the rest of the West Bank and thereby preclude the possibility of a future contiguous Palestinian state.
· E1 is mostly inhabited by Bedouin, who make their living by herding livestock.
· Annexation: According to the Times of Israel, at the request of President Trump’s administration, a bill to unilaterally annex Ma’ale Adumim and the surrounding area has been postponed — but Khan al Ahmar and the many other villages within that annexation footprint still face the very real threat of demolition.
· Emboldened by the new US administration, the Israeli settler movement pushed through a radical new law on February 6, 2017 now referred to as the ‘Regulation Law’. The Knesset passed legislation that allows for the seizure of private Palestinian property, in an effort to retroactively legalize settlements built on stolen land.
· The question of jurisdiction is key here. The reason this law is so dangerous is that by taking this action, the Knesset has asserted control over land for which they have no jurisdiction. By international law, only Israel’s military can administer occupied land. When the Knesset passed this bill, they asserted de facto annexation.
· Many express concern that because this law directly violates the Fourth Geneva Convention, it will be grounds for a case against Israel in The Hague.
What we are asking you to do
· So far, Belgium, Brazil, Canada, Denmark, EU, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, UK and UN (OCHA, OHCHR, UNRWA and UNSCO) have all sent their top representatives – Consuls General and Representatives – to visit Khan al Ahmar in a show of solidarity.
· Members of Congress are uniquely able to get the attention of the Government of Israel. We’ve found that when Senate and House offices call the Israeli Embassy and the U.S. State Department, they keep villages standing.
· This was true for Al Aqaba village, where Rebuilding Alliance helped build their kindergarten, and also for Susiya and Umm Al Kheir. We now ask your help to keep Khan al Ahmar standing too.
- Jahalin Solidarity, www.jahalin.org, will soon be releasing:
High Hopes, a film by Oscar Award nominee and International Emmy Award Winner Guy Davidi, Produced by Angela Godfrey-Goldstein, Music Pink Floyd
View the Trailer
- Record number of demolitions and displacements in the West Bank during 2016
United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs
Posted on 10 February 2017 as part of The Monthly Humanitarian Bulletin
"During January 2017, OCHA recorded the demolition of 140 structures by
the Israeli authorities, displacing around 240 Palestinians and affecting another 4,000. The number of structures demolished during the first month of the year was over 50 per cent higher than the monthly average of structures targeted in 2016" [the year with most demolitions ever recorded]
- B'Tselem Video | Stop-work orders served in Khan al-Ahmar, Feb. 2017
On 19 February 2017, large numbers of Civil Administration personnel and police arrived at the Khan al-Ahmar community, which is located ...
- Israeli Hard-Liners Want to ‘Go Big’: Annex an Israeli Settelement
by Ian Fisher NYTimes Jan. 30, 2017
Quoting Eid Abu Khamis, spokesperson for Khan Al Ahmar
- Khan al Ahmar article on Wikipedia
- Protesters organize sit-in at Khan al-Ahmar school slated for demolition
Maan News Agency, Feb. 23, 2017
- Development of E-1, in Ir Amim’s newsletter:
- Ir Amim’s Position on the Proposed Legislation to Annex Ma’ale Adumim
- The Bulldozers and the Bedouin
by Amira Hass about Khan al Ahmar, Haaretz, Feb 24, 2017
- Prime Minister, don’t annex Ma’ale Adumim
by Major General (Ret.) Amnon Reshef is Founder and Chairman of Commanders for Israel's Security, Times of Israel